The Redpoint Crux: Giselle or Phantom of the Opera?

The Redpoint Crux by Morgan Shamy is interesting. I thought that when it said "dying girls" that the girls would be the ones dying, not the men. My main issue with the book is that it should have stuck with Giselle or The Phantom of the Opera, not both. And I found the reason for why the girls were dying a little far fetched. And I have so many questions the more I sat on the book and thought about it. Believe it or not I read this book over a month ago, and I am struggling to come to terms with the book. I bought a kindle edition hoping the formatting would not be so weird on that one, and maybe the book will make sense.

I liked Red and Liam, for me they were the most believable characters and I could see a love interest between them, but I could not see it for the characters that do wind up getting together. It felt false to me, but that could just be me.

It was not a "oh wow where has this book been all my life" story for me, and for that reason I am giving it a 3.5 star rating.